State not obligated to pay exonerated inmates

By Timberly Ross The Associated Press
Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 - 12:08:06 pm CST

OMAHA -- Three people recently freed after spending nearly 20 years in prison for a murder they didn’t commit face many challenges as they re-enter society: finding jobs and a place to live, achieving financial stability and fighting negative perceptions about ex-convicts.

And because they live in Nebraska, they’ll likely do so without the state’s financial help.

In some states, exonerated inmates are entitled to government compensation, but there’s no such law in Nebraska, leaving them to rebuild their lives on their own.

Heather Weigand of the Berkeley, Calif.-based Life After Exoneration Program, which helps the wrongfully convicted get back on their feet, said there’s evidence that exonorees experience the same trauma as torture victims and war veterans.

“They’re victims that we then re-victimize by not having services available,” she said. “We have to right the wrongs, and the government has really failed.”

Twenty-five states and the District of Columbia have compensation laws, according to The Innocence Project, a New York-based legal center specializing in wrongful conviction cases.

In Louisiana, for example, exonerated inmates can get $15,000 for each year of incarceration, with a $150,000 cap. California allows $100 per day in compensation.

Some state laws also provide compensation for lost wages and offer tuition waivers.

“I think that in the appropriate case, that’s exactly what should happen,” said attorney Jerry Soucie, who works with the Nebraska Commission on Public Advocacy. “However, we don’t have such a law on our books right now.”

Soucie represents Thomas Winslow, who was cleared this fall in the 1985 murder of Helen Wilson of Beatrice. He said state lawmakers should consider passing a law to compensate the wrongfully convicted.

But so far, such a measure doesn’t appear to have much support among lawmakers.

An aide in Sen. Brad Ashford’s office said there’s been no indication that legislation to compensate exonorees would be introduced in the session starting Jan. 7. Ashford is chairman of the Legislature’s Judiciary Committee, which would have to take up such legislation.

In states without compensation programs, some inmates sue and are awarded millions of dollars.

Doug Stratton, an attorney for Joseph White, who was also recently exonerated in Wilson’s murder, said he’ll contact all six people wrongfully convicted in the case to see if there’s interest in a lawsuit.

The Wilson case was the first time inmates have been freed in Nebraska based on DNA evidence.

Last week, state Attorney General Jon Bruning said DNA evidence conclusively links Bruce Allen Smith of Oklahoma to Wilson’s rape and murder.

Smith was among the original suspects in the case, but evidence tested as part of the initial investigation appeared to exclude him as a suspect. Newer DNA tests performed recently showed that the earlier test result was flawed.

Smith died of AIDS in 1992.

Winslow, White and Ada JoAnn Taylor were freed because of the DNA evidence, while the other three were released from prison in 1994, after the completion of their sentences.

Bruning has said he will pursue full pardons for all six.

Since post-conviction DNA testing was first allowed in 1989, the results have exonerated 223 people, according to the Innocence Project, whose figures do not include the six Nebraskans cleared in the Wilson case. Seventeen of those had been on death row.

Most states, including Nebraska, have laws that allow for the testing.

Innocence Project spokesman Eric Ferrero said compensation for wrongful convictions is needed because re-entering society after serving prison time is difficult, even with an exoneration.

“Some people don’t have family support or any network of supports when they get out,” he said. “They often get out with no money, no job experience -- other than prison jobs -- and they often lack the skills to get reintegrated into society and rebuild their lives.”

Leave a Comment

All posts are subject to our Terms and Standards.
Your posted comment will appear after it has been approved.
   
Ranger04
Nov 18, 2008 8:04 PM
It is a shame that there could be such a miscarriage of justice and those found NOT guilty are not compensated by the state. They should be able to sue the state and the prosecutors that brought charges against them in the first place.Nebraska seems to be behind the times when it comes to common sense legislation. Look at the mess that the Safe Haven law has become.
John Lloyd Scharf
Nov 19, 2008 10:14 AM
I am not happy that we do not see a plan

to change the policies and procedures that produced this injustice.

How many people are in prison for whom the DNA is not relevant in

the case, but the way they were convicted is? How can you trust a

system that stays the same and innocent people are imprisoned at a cost to the people?
Print This Story Email This Story
25 states compensate the wrongly convicted

Twenty-five states and the District of Columbia have laws that provide compensation for the wrongfully convicted. Here’s a look at what the laws allow:

• Alabama: $50,000 minimum per year of wrongful incarceration

• California: $100 maximum per day

• Connecticut: No prescribed amount or limit

• District of Columbia: No prescribed amount or limit

• Florida: $50,000 per year, up to $2 million

• Illinois: $85,350 for those who served up to 5 years, $170,000 for 5 to 14 years and $199,150 for more than 14 years

• Iowa: $50 per day, up to $25,000 a year

• Louisiana: $15,000 per year, with a $150,000 limit

• Maine: $300,000 limit

• Maryland: No prescribed amount or limit

• Massachusetts: $500,000 limit

• Missouri: $50 per day

• Montana: Money for education only

• New Hampshire: $20,000 limit

• New Jersey: Twice the annual income in year prior to incarceration or $20,000 per year, whichever is greater

• New York: No prescribed amount or limit

• North Carolina: $50,000 per year, with a $750,000 limit

• Ohio: $40,330, or other amount decided by state auditor, per year

• Oklahoma: $175,000 total

• Tennessee: $1 million total

• Texas: $50,000 per year; $100,000 per year if on death row

• Utah: State’s average annual wage per year, for up to 15 years of incarceration

• Vermont: $30,000 to $60,000 per year

• Virginia: 90 percent of state’s per capita personal income per year for up to 20 years

• West Virginia: No prescribed amount or limit

• Wisconsin: $25,000 limit

In addition to a financial payment, some state laws also provide compensation for lost wages and offer tuition waivers.

In some states, exonerated inmates must meet specific requirements, such as receiving a government pardon or not giving a false conviction, to be eligible for compensation.

Source: The Innocence Project, Florida Legislature, Utah Legislature

Hot Topics

Blogs

Calendar of Events

Photos