Study: Immigrant input equals $1.6B

By Jean Ortiz The Associated Press
Wednesday, Oct 15, 2008 - 11:36:55 am CDT

OMAHA -- Immigrants add $1.6 billion annually in spending to the state’s economy and fill a critical role in the work force, according to a new study to be released today by the University of Nebraska at Omaha.

Officials with the university’s Office of Latino/Latin American Studies, or OLLAS, who issued the report, called the study the first quantitative, statewide assessment of the contributions Nebraska immigrants -- both legal and illegal -- make to the state’s economy.

Available data didn’t allow the report’s authors to differentiate between the economic impact of illegal versus legal immigrants.

But the policy brief does make a few inferences -- the first being that undocumented migrants are largely employed and are contributing to production, employment and taxes similar to legal immigrants.

“Moreover, it would be reasonable to also assume that the economic contributions of unauthorized immigrants are more than likely underestimated by all accounts, and that their public costs are likely lower than for authorized immigrants or the native born as a whole,” a draft of the policy brief says.

The report’s author, Christopher Decker, an assistant professor of economics, was traveling and unavailable for comment on the study’s methodology or other details Tuesday. Jerry Deichert with the university’s Center for Public Affairs Research also contributed to the report.

Deichert and OLLAS Director Lourdes Gouveia did not return phone messages Tuesday seeking comment.

According to a draft of an policy brief that summarizes the report’s key findings and lays out policy recommendations, immigrants created about 12,000 jobs across all sectors of the state’s economy in 2006.

And the loss of the foreign-born work force could cost the state $13.5 billion and thousands of jobs.

The loss of immigrants would be devastating for the state’s economy, particularly in communities whose main industries depend on the “injection of a new and young labor force and a generation of children willing to stay in those communities,” OLLAS officials write in the policy brief.

Immigrants make up 5.6 percent of the state’s population, according to the report. It’s a 33 percent increase since 2000. But immigrants represent only 4.28 percent of the public sector costs to the state.

OLLAS officials lay out several recommendations, including federal immigration reform to remove unnecessary impediments to citizenship, state and local efforts focused on immigrant and community integration and improved training programs, including those that boost English proficiency.

The brief goes on to say the report presents an opportunity to move from the “politics of division” -- fueled by misunderstandings or denial -- to the “politics of immigrant and community integration.

The state’s leadership must reject “paralyzing, anti-immigrant and anti-Hispanic rhetoric that often passes as informed analysis,” according to the report, and instead craft “informed policies that will prevent us from squandering immigrants’ contributions.”

Leave a Comment

All posts are subject to our Terms and Standards.
Your posted comment will appear after it has been approved.
   
azhusker
Oct 15, 2008 1:15 PM
Immigrant (illegal) spending does not diminish the cost to taxpayers in welfare and health care costs....
sickofit
Oct 15, 2008 3:03 PM
come to the Schuyler Golf Club tonight at 7 p.m. and listen to the citizens there voice their concerns about illegal aliens.
rob g
Oct 15, 2008 4:07 PM
In 1985 an uneducated worker could get a job at Schuyler pack for about a $12 an hour starting wage. That would be like about $20 today. It is very hard work and I respect anyone who works there. Today they are not only undercutting the hard working non-educated white workers, but they are also taking advantage of the uneducated hispanics by not paying them a fair wage for that very hard work. This biased and one sided article would have you believe we would all be on food stamps without the surge of illegals to our state. Nothing is further from the truth. This story is nothing more than a one sided piece of propaganda and the Telegram should be more carefull with the stories they pick up!
Yazzer
Oct 15, 2008 4:47 PM
I would like to see an INDEPENDENT study. This is so one sided it isn't even funny.
kitty
Oct 15, 2008 7:36 PM
That's odd. I just read a report that said the illegal immigrants are costing this country billions every year. Oh well, it depends on who is talking, so there are probably falsehoods on both sides. But let's face it, the illegals and all immigrants are being exploited. It's all about greed and corruption in the business sector. The illegals are pawns. But if they can earn something to send back to their country and still have something for themselves, they don't mind being a pawn. We can only hope they will become legal through the proper channels, learn English, and become loyal US citizens. Don't depend on our government to make these people disappear. Contact your reps in Congress, and tell them to enforce our laws. Meanwhile, the illegals who become citizens should be accepted as all those before them were accepted.
R.U. Serious
Oct 15, 2008 9:00 PM
Funny how the article mentions how much money illegals BRING IN to the economy of Nebraska, but the cost associated with them is only a percentage of an unknown or unmentioned number. It's wonderful how a supposed unbiased source of info can twist a story however they see fit. This article should never have seen the light of day. Shame on you Telegram, why don't you just print your paper in Spanish and call it good.
zahusker
Oct 15, 2008 10:30 PM
(azhusker) you Do have to have legal status to be on welfare....just thought i'd let you know.
MeMyselfAndI
Oct 16, 2008 12:26 AM
To: zahusker, actually, no. You just have to have a fake ID. As for rob g: We often don't agree but on this one you are spot on. I have relatives that worked at the pack in Schuyler in the 80s. After the illegals came in they were making less in the early 90s than they were in the mid 80s, so they moved on to better jobs at BD in Columbus. As for the argument that illegals/immigrants do the jobs Americans won't do, it's crap. Americans just wont do it for the same pay illegals/immigrants will do it for. It's modern day corporate slavery and it's wrong. In the mid 90s the meatpackers union did a study and at that time it would have only taken a five cent raise in the price of beef to double the pay of the average meatpacking line worker's salery. That would have kept the jobs with Americans. Nobody reports on that. Americans aren't lazy or too good as the illegal/immigrant rights folks want you to believe, they just aren't willing to be voluntary slaves, like others are.
focused
Oct 16, 2008 7:29 AM
The war in Iraq goes bad, our economy goes to the tank, and Bubba looks to the immigrant as the scapegoat. Sorry Bubba, you're looking in the wrong direction. Try looking in the direction of George, Dick, and unregulated big business. If the war and the economy were not such huge disasters, we wouldn't even be discussing immigrants!
azhusker
Oct 16, 2008 12:58 PM
zahusker, like memyselfandI said, stolen identities are commonplace with illegals, that's how they get jobs. You watch, this article will have many comments as this issue is a huge part of future America's fate.
azhusker
Oct 16, 2008 1:04 PM
To focused....sorry, but before the war and bad economy, WE were focused on illegal immigration (meaning all involved in illegal activities including George and big business)and would be even if other things demand our attention. If you lived in the southwest, you'd see what it brings to communities. How does safe haven city Schuyler look now to those that grew up there? Not pretty, is it?
rob g
Oct 16, 2008 5:14 PM
To MemyselfandI: It must feel pretty good for all three of you to be right about something for once... Just jabbing you with a little fun. Thanks for the support on this one.
P.Smith
Oct 16, 2008 5:16 PM
What a one sided piece of drivel. If you want facts about the cost to the American Taxpayer, this group needs to talk to L.A. County Supervisor Mike Antonovich. He gives a running monthly total cost to L.A. county that illegal aliens are costing just ONE county in the U.S. It's no wonder no one was available for questioning this article. Put it where it belongs, in the trash or wrap your dogs stuff with it.
zwiddlez
Oct 16, 2008 6:11 PM
Anyone else remember the post from awhile back from a wife of an illegal immigrant who has a husband that stole an identity and had to pay child support because of it?????????

And we the readers are supposed to feel bad for the family.
chicago Mike
Oct 16, 2008 7:21 PM
You can look at this report in the context of Schuyler pack, and then multiply it a thousand times to cover all the other businesses that employ aliens.This report acts as though Schuyler pack would close if not for Aliens, and all the economic activity associated with it would simply cease to exist. In truth, as Rob G. said, these used to be good , high paying union jobs, which is only right, as the work is hard, unpleasant and quite dangerous. So now we have low payed Aliens sending back part of their paycheck to their home country, instead of relatively high paid union meat packers spending, saving, and investing in Schuyler and Columbus. 1.6 billion dollars?, if Americans were still doing these jobs it would probably be 2.6 billion dollars!
rob g
Oct 17, 2008 10:36 PM
well said Chicago Mike' Considering the "Cesspool" you live in, I am happy to know that you still have a clear head.
McGruff
Oct 17, 2008 10:55 PM
Finally, a reasonable explaination for why Schuyler is the Beverly Hills of Nebraska.
Print This Story Email This Story

Hot Topics

Blogs

Calendar of Events

Photos